climateprediction.net home page

The world's largest climate forecasting experiment for the 21st century.

Credits not updating


Advanced search

Message boards : Number crunching : Credits not updating

AuthorMessage
Profile Saenger
Avatar
Send message
Joined: Nov 1 04
Posts: 178
Credit: 1,230,271
RAC: 0
Message 40751 - Posted 23 Sep 2010 22:17:34 UTC

    Any reason why there is the current stoppage in credit counting?
    Or is it reduced to once every few days since Tolu left? ;)
    ____________
    Gruesse vom Saenger

    For questions about Boinc look in the BOINC-Wiki

    Les Bayliss
    Forum moderator
    Send message
    Joined: Sep 5 04
    Posts: 5121
    Credit: 8,414,613
    RAC: 3,913
    Message 40752 - Posted 23 Sep 2010 22:31:40 UTC - in response to Message 40751.

      It's because a script has stopped running, and Milo is on a much delayed and deserved holiday.


      ____________
      Backups: Here

      Profile scottishwebcamslive.com
      Avatar
      Send message
      Joined: Jun 21 06
      Posts: 26
      Credit: 8,397,236
      RAC: 2,705
      Message 40754 - Posted 24 Sep 2010 3:07:18 UTC

        hello,

        thought this script was an automatic system ?

        any idea when Milo will be back ?

        best regards
        Ian
        ____________
        ----> Please Join team Scotland HERE

        Profile Ron Crouch
        Avatar
        Send message
        Joined: Feb 24 05
        Posts: 31
        Credit: 6,021,632
        RAC: 1,432
        Message 40756 - Posted 24 Sep 2010 5:15:47 UTC

          I suppose I have a different take on this credit business. As long as my units run, and whether they complete or crash is immaterial. I look upon it as my tiny contribution to help further the understanding of the underlying science. For me credits are meaningless (you can have my air miles too).

          ian.sm
          Send message
          Joined: Oct 4 09
          Posts: 73
          Credit: 7,242,427
          RAC: 0
          Message 40760 - Posted 24 Sep 2010 8:17:57 UTC - in response to Message 40756.

            I suppose I have a different take on this credit business. As long as my units run, and whether they complete or crash is immaterial. I look upon it as my tiny contribution to help further the understanding of the underlying science. For me credits are meaningless (you can have my air miles too).

            Tend to agree.

            Ban credits! If that happened, the projects would lose many participants (i.e. credit hunters) but, at least, those who remained would be revealed as being 100% committed to the project's objectives.

            My team has custom stats which counts completed models. Over 4k to date. Am very happy with my own contribution in contrast to the controversial measure of credits!

            Also, imo, another more meaningful number is equivalent SM3 years.

            Credits are even more controversial when considering combined BOINC stats. Apart from the obvious variations between CPU and GPU projects, there is not even a level playing field between CPU projects. CPDN does not "pay" as well as many other projects. So what?

            Anyway, Milo certainly deserves his holiday. The only concern with the lack of cover since Tolu's departure is what would happen if there was another major (or even minor) server problem?



            Profile mo.v
            Forum moderator
            Avatar
            Send message
            Joined: Sep 29 04
            Posts: 2354
            Credit: 6,485,473
            RAC: 3,294
            Message 40761 - Posted 24 Sep 2010 9:53:40 UTC

              Milo fixed a breakdown of many functions on the independent forum the other day and he did it from afar. But while away from Oxford he's only prepared to do this for serious malfunctions which is to be expected. I'm afraid he doesn't consider the credit script failure to be a serious malfunction. After all, we'll get all our credits later when the script is running again; they're delayed, not lost.

              Milo's going to give login rights to one of the researchers next week which will reduce the risks associated with him being CPDN's only programmer at the moment. But there are a lot of things that I'm sure none of the researchers would know how to do.

              The credits script is of course supposed to run automatically but occasionally it just stops, sometimes for no apparent reason. Critical functions like a server disk almost filling up send Milo a warning, but the credits script isn't considered a critical function.

              Credits do motivate quite a lot of crunchers, which is a good thing, and some members check on them as an indication that everything is working properly; that's another good thing. The credits also help motivate teams; I don't think there's much doubt that belonging to a team, particularly one whose members can communicate with each other, helps crunchers sort out problems and keep their computers working properly.
              ____________
              Cpdn news
              5 CPDN READMEs

              DJStarfox
              Send message
              Joined: Jan 27 07
              Posts: 254
              Credit: 1,127,430
              RAC: 515
              Message 40762 - Posted 24 Sep 2010 13:18:32 UTC - in response to Message 40761.

                Totally agree. If I were in Milo's shoes, I would want another trustworthy programmer there to handle things while I was on holiday and to help with all the work day-to-day. As long as credits will queue properly, there's no problem. Good luck in the job search.

                Profile Dave Jackson
                Send message
                Joined: May 15 09
                Posts: 604
                Credit: 580,936
                RAC: 203
                Message 40763 - Posted 24 Sep 2010 13:59:07 UTC - in response to Message 40762.

                  No problem with Milo having a holiday - I have read enough that I am sure he has more than earned it! From some of the posts I have read elsewhere I am sure that stats do help motivate people. - I would still be running cpdn without them but do like to check the stats regularly. I was horrified to see on one of the threads someone saying they would suspend activity for the project till some issue with stats was sorted out.

                  Profile Strathpeffer
                  Avatar
                  Send message
                  Joined: Jan 9 07
                  Posts: 482
                  Credit: 283,923
                  RAC: 272
                  Message 40764 - Posted 24 Sep 2010 14:30:13 UTC - in response to Message 40761.

                    Last modified: 24 Sep 2010 14:31:00 UTC

                    Credits do motivate quite a lot of crunchers, which is a good thing, and some members check on them as an indication that everything is working properly; that's another good thing. The credits also help motivate teams; I don't think there's much doubt that belonging to a team, particularly one whose members can communicate with each other, helps crunchers sort out problems and keep their computers working properly.

                    Words of wisdom from mo.v as always ;-)

                    But I'm sure those of us with any sense will be happy enough to wait for our credits until Milo gets back from his well-deserved holiday (actually, I could do with one of those myself!). I hope he's having a lovely relaxing time doing whatever he enjoys and not having to think about work too much!

                    Dave, are you sure the person you mention wasn't just planning to suspend network activity? That just means you continue to crunch but stop your computer from trying to send trickles. And it's sometimes a good idea to do that if there's a problem with a server - your trickles just get saved until the server is working again, and then you get a "mega-trickle". Some people do that as a matter of course anyway.
                    ____________
                    Visit the Scotland team

                    Profile prairie69
                    Send message
                    Joined: Oct 7 07
                    Posts: 5
                    Credit: 178,435
                    RAC: 0
                    Message 40766 - Posted 24 Sep 2010 19:00:00 UTC

                      Just got a huge amount of credits. Thanks!

                      prairie69
                      Vermont, USA

                      John Eric Hopkinson
                      Send message
                      Joined: Jan 27 05
                      Posts: 47
                      Credit: 428,606
                      RAC: 0
                      Message 40768 - Posted 24 Sep 2010 22:34:19 UTC - in response to Message 40756.

                        Right on Ron. The credit assignment to my performance is so haywire that I have suggested that credits be assigned to those crunchers who ask for them.
                        Par example, I shut down for a disk massage recently,following completion of a Famous model; upgraded to BOINC 58, rebooted, and the credits rate fell off the screen. Was I worried? nada.
                        It appears to me that Milo would enjoy better weekends and more sleep if credits were restricted to the hotshots.
                        But perhaps even that doesn't make sense. Consider this: my RAC ranges about 260-275, on my Thinkpad oldtimer; mo.v today shows RAC about 40 for 3 pretty fast machines. (Apples and Oranges?) So,where is the comparability and who gives a damn?
                        ____________

                        Profile astroWX
                        Forum moderator
                        Send message
                        Joined: Aug 5 04
                        Posts: 1250
                        Credit: 34,827,810
                        RAC: 21,756
                        Message 40769 - Posted 25 Sep 2010 5:31:57 UTC

                          John,

                          Mo participates heavily in Beta development work. Beta total credits appear here (usually) but RAC never does.

                          HTH.
                          ____________
                          "We have met the enemy and he is us." -- Pogo
                          Greetings from coastal Washington state, the scenic US Pacific Northwest.

                          John Eric Hopkinson
                          Send message
                          Joined: Jan 27 05
                          Posts: 47
                          Credit: 428,606
                          RAC: 0
                          Message 40772 - Posted 25 Sep 2010 15:08:11 UTC - in response to Message 40769.

                            Neat. Thanks AstroWX. I will track down a more comparable data point.
                            But I will never know everything about these workings. Entertaining mysteries.
                            P.S. That "important stuff" URL reaches into some pretty ancient MikeMars history (2006..?)

                            Any hurricanes up your way this year?
                            ____________

                            Post to thread

                            Message boards : Number crunching : Credits not updating




                            Copyright © 2002-2014 climateprediction.net